Did you check Tire Rack's customer ratings, Jay? I usually start with that, then ask around.
Michelin Defender is rated highly, and my supplier said he hasn't had complaints with out of round, tread separation, and out of balance as they have with many others (even motorcycle tires). Supposedly this is due to using inconsistent recycled materials in an attempt to be "green". I got no problem with recycling - if it works!
@Burla They were on backorder anyway.
I got 20" rims, I decided to go with Goodyear Workhorse HT which is a commercial tire, highly rated - not like their crappy ST consumer tire (one of the worst ratings & a factory tire on the 1500). Put them on in April, so far I like them a lot.